Why aren’t physicists scientists?

Short answer:

amateur –> scientist

professional –> anti-science

Academic physicists are professionals therefore they cannot be scientists. But physicists as professionals have the hereditary right to define science.

  • Physicists defined science as what physicists do.

The propaganda that physics is science is so well established that physicists use the two words interchangeably. Here for instance Sean Carroll, a Doctor of Philosophy practicing cosmology, a sort of degenerate physics, calls himself “I, a scientist.”

In a previous paragraph he describes what he does: He is attempting to build a time machine.

Therefore, Doctor Sean Carroll implicitly defines a scientist to be someone who builds theoretical time machines.

  • A time machine is the Hollywood name for violation of conservation laws.

You may or may not agree with this definition but the fact is that whatever physicists do they define as science.

So reading the mind of god is defined as science.

Investigating the universe before universe existed becomes science.

Because this is what physicists do.

But questioning a legal but corrupt physics experiment is not science.

Because physicists never question legal physics.

  • Physics is a profession therefore it is not science.

As professionals physicists must believe without question the doctrine of the profession.

  • Professionals are not scientists they are professionals.

 


3 Responses to “Professionals are professionals”  

  1. 1 Walter L. Johnson

    This is the most rambling, confusing, nonsense I have ever read. Everyone is an artist, but no one is a physicist unless they have a Ph.D. in Physics and everyone in the world knows that, but the word scientist is not trademarked.

  2. 2 Pioneer1

    Walter,

    Thanks for the comment. As I see it, the difference between art and physics is that art is based on questioning authority. Academic physics practiced by professional physicists is a legal profession based on not questioning authority.

    I believe that science is about questioning authority. Do you agree with this?

    The word scientist is not trademarked but its meaning is owned by physicists.

  1. 1 Professionals are professionals 2 at Freedom of Science


Leave a Reply





Close
Powered by ShareThis